After the Supreme Court struck down his original 2025 tranche of global tariffs in February, President Donald Trump’s administration has imposed a variety of other tariffs using different justifications. And those new tariffs are also facing challenges in the courts.
Tariffs have been an ongoing challenge for the branded merchandise industry, from stifling uncertainty caused by changing rates and policies to squeezed margins and supply chain disruptions.
RELATED: PPAI Research: The Tariff Effects, From Refunds To End Buyers And Operations
Section 301 Forced Labor Tariffs
In July, the administration imposed double-digit tariffs on virtually all imports, citing forced labor concerns under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974. Within hours, the same coalition of small businesses that successfully sued to stop the 2025 global tariffs filed suit filed suit against the new duties in the U.S. Court of International Trade.
Attorneys for the plaintiffs have argued that the U.S. Trade Representative’s report doesn’t provide sufficient detail to justify the forced labor tariffs. In particular, plaintiffs say the investigations were rushed and the report lacks the country-specific findings that a Section 301 tariff requires.
Don’t Miss A Thing: SUBSCRIBE To PPAI Newslink
- A separate but concurrent Section 301 investigation into Vietnam’s intellectual property practices remains ongoing and has been extended into February.
Retaliatory Tariffs On Canadian Goods
Also in July, the White House announced a new round of tariffs on specific goods from Canada. Using a nearly 100-year-old law, the president signed three proclamations to impose additional 50% tariffs on certain goods imported from Canada in response to Canadian trade policies regarding vehicles, alcohol and dairy products.
- Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 allows for tariffs of up to 50% on imports from specific countries.
Relations between the U.S. and Canada took a sharp turn over the next 30 days, sparking a trade war with multiple rounds of counter-tariff announcements from both sides. In September, the U.S. enacted an import ban on nearly $1 billion worth of Canadian goods.
In October, food importer Gellert Global Group filed suit with the Court of International Trade, asking the court to declare the new tariffs on Canadian goods illegal, stop their collection and refund importers that have already paid them. The lawsuit argues that the administration exceeded its authority under the statute, failed to make the required factual finding of discrimination to enact tariffs under Section 338 and failed to comply with the law’s 30-day waiting period for newly listed products.
- Several former U.S. trade officials have filed friend-of-the-court briefs in support of invalidating the Section 338 tariffs and ordering refunds.
States Sue Over Section 122 Tariffs
A group of 25 of U.S. states filed suit together in March to challenge the Trump administration’s 10% tariffs under Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974. On May 7, the Court of International Trade ruled this round of tariffs are “invalid” and “unauthorized by law,” but the trio of judges granted an injunction pausing the 10% duty only for the three parties found to have standing in the lawsuit: two small business and Washington state.
- The administration appealed the decision and was granted a stay, which means importers are still paying the Section 122 tariffs while the appeal progresses in the courts.
Kyle Sanders
Partner with Thorn Run Partners, PPAI’s lobbying team in Washington
IEEPA Refunds Continue
Meanwhile, CBP continues to issue court-ordered refunds of the invalidated tariffs enacted in 2025 under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. The third phase of tariff refunds covering finally liquidated entries was launched on October 6, and as of November 5, U.S. Customs and Border Protection has processed, certified and sent for payment a total of approximately $128 billion.
The administration has argued that it can’t refund finally liquidated entries without a specific court order, but an October 8 order from the Court of International Trade certified a broad class of importers, paving the way for refund eligibility to a wider range of businesses, particularly smaller firms without the resources to file suit individually in the trade court. The administration has appealed the order to the Federal Circuit, but on November 13, the court also suspended a two-year time limit for importers in the certified class, extending their access to refund rights.
Legislative Tariff Relief On The Horizon?
Washington news sources report that congressional Democrats are preparing an aggressive legislative strategy to challenge and roll back Trump’s tariffs. This includes a plan to introduce a bill to rescind the Canada tariffs early in the new session.
“What does that mean for PPAI? We’re likely to have a much more receptive audience on the Hill to tariff relief,” says Kyle Sanders, partner with Thorn Run Partners and a member of PPAI’s lobbying team in Washington. “The Democrats who overwhelmingly won on Nov. 3 are using that outcome as an opportunity to highlight what they view as pressure points that Americans are feeling.”
During PPAI’s Legislative Education & Action Day in April, a group of PPAI members met with senior legislative staffers for incoming Senate Finance Committee Chair Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Oregon), who were very receptive to the industry’s call for tariff relief. Just days after the election, Wyden himself told Oregon Public Broadcasting that trade policy will be a top priority,” adding, “we’re also going to make an effort to end the tariffs with Canada because that’s damaging to both sides.”
Join Us To Support The Industry In Washington: Register Your Interest In Attending LEAD 2027
LEAD 2027 is tentatively set for April 12, pending confirmation against the congressional calendar when it’s released early in the new year. Look for the application portal to open shortly after The PPAI Expo in late January. The event will continue to focus on asking for clear, deliberative and predictable trade policy, such as long-term renewal of the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement and the African Growth & Opportunity Act.
PPAI will continue to monitor these developments and provide updates, as well as opportunities to raise your voice in support of industry priorities. Subscribe to PPAI Newslink to have these delivered straight to your inbox twice a week.